Thursday, February 15, 2007

Bill Miller's 4Q 2006 Commentary

At the end of 2006, one of the most talked-about streaks in value investing (heck, in any kind of investing) came to an end. Bill Miller's Legg Mason Value Trust failed to outperform the S&P 500 Index for the first calendar year since he took over sole management of the fund in 1990. Rumours about the end of the streak led to a lot of publicity and commentary and only added fuel to the fire when the firm announced in late October that they expected 2Q 2007 net income to come in below analyst estimates.

In the letter, Miller acknowledges the streak right up front. Making use of both a priori and a posteriori probabilities, he demonstrates the odds that one could replicate his success. Needless to say, "there was probably some skill involved". That said, he doesn't allow himself to be satisfied with having done something that most probably could not, and in doing so, demonstrates the kind of character that is difficult to find in an industry where "just getting by" still compensates you pretty darn well.
Active managers are paid to add value over what can be earned at a low cost from passive investing ... We are paid to a do a job and we didn't do it this year, which is what the end of the streak means, and I am not at all happy or relieved about that.
The remainder of the commentary is spent on reviewing Miller's investment principles and singling out a few of the reasons why the streak lasted as long as it did. Two sources of outperformance for those 15 years that he finds applicable to investing in general: valuation and portfolio construction.

On valuation:
Valuation is inherently uncertain, since it involves the future. As I often remind our analysts, 100% of the information you have about a company represents the past, and 100% of the value depends on the future
And on portfolio construction:
We construct our portfolios the way theory says one should, which is different from the way many, if not most construct their portfolios ... We want our clients and shareholders to own a portfolio actively chosen based on long-term value, not based on index concentration.
He touches on other topics that helped the outperformance, such as factor diversification and concentration, and on being willing to take advantage of errors made by others, due to social psychological cognitive errors (read: behavioural finance).
It is trying to invest long-term in a short-term world, and being contrarian when conformity is more comfortable, and being willing to court controversy and be wrong, that has helped us outperform.
Miller's letters are always a treat, but this one serves both as a nice summary of his thoughts on investing to date, as well as an example of the type of humility that true investors always possess, even if their results do have odds of 1 in 2.3 million.

eta: actually putting a link to the letter in the post would probably help. it can be found here [warning: .pdf]

Any one looking for free stock market tips may please visit:
Investment in Stocks requires a lot of research and background work. For more details please visit
Here is an abridged version of my upcoming book.

"The Four Filters Invention of Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger" by Bud Labitan
Nice Buffett blog. Care to exchange links? I am the editor of, which tracks the investment activities of the world's greatest investors, including the Oracle of Omaha himself.

Stop on by at:

Christopher E. Hill
"Tracking The World's Greatest Investors"
This is a great blog with very helpful information.

So many complex factors are involved in valuing securities and building solid portfolios.

I am new to the world of investing and I hope to one day be able to say that I have continuously outperformed the S&P 500.

Check out my blog at:
I am a student of South China Agriculture University.I want a better blog,mine is,
can you give me some advice,Thank you!
Want to know...Ideas of warren buffet to billionaire
so log on
good posting...warren buffet has a great ideas for invesmtnts...
Check this out Buffett Fans$2.1_million_price_tag.html
I always thought Miller missed some of the basics. He had way to much of Legg Mason in Google. No where near enough diversification.

Great post!
Dear Mr Warren Buffett:

i would like to ask you to do me a flavor,which is give the letter to the Paramount leader of the People's Republic of China(Mr Hu Jintao)or the Premier of the state council of the people's republic of China(Mr Wen Jiabao)

My father's property had been demolished in 2001 by the Chu Hai (three good)real estate.The demolished of the buildings in chu hai was enforced by the local government.

My father has been negotiating and fight against the China government through lawyers since 2001.Now,he has finally got the law by his side,after the logal government sign the paper,which is his property is legal for certain area (legally approved);therefore,according to the law,he should has the proper compensation.
Although,the real estate and the China government could not denied it:However,the real estate try to leave the whole responsible to the China government.the real estate resist on only give out the second hand houses with bad quality,which is that kind of act is illegal.On the other hand,the Chu Hai government only tell my father to negotiate with the real estate.Until now,the negotiation is still processing in a very slow pattern.

There is a way that we can solve the problem quickly,which is to get help from you or the democratic party (The President of the United States)or Angela Dorothea Merkel ( The Chancellor of Germany)}:Because Angela Dorothea Merkel had been help a lady name Sum Ting,whose case is similar as ours,but more complicated and difficult than our case.
If i can send the letter to Mr Hu Jintao and Mr Wen Jiabao through you,this can be over soon as our case is only notice the top level of Chinna government.Because the letters that were sent to them from us seemed had never reached the hands of the China top leaders.

p.s: P.S i was a year 1 university student of Macquarie in Sydney a year ago:nevetheless,this thing has kept me away from studying in may not believe it,but'i think i've got the talent of investing in finacial industry like you and george soros ,i probably got 50%for both of your ability or instinct,not knowledges.but i do know what you mean the future is unpredictable,because you ,george soros,albert einstein is the father of inspiration to me ,and now you are my only hope.

your faithfully

Lo Wing Chi(Hong Kong Citizen)

contact no:home 26798903
Here is an idea from ua Corp. Mr. Warren Buffet.

A stock trading system where you set the software to buy and sell...


Buy at 1.00 ... sell at 2.00

Ty for hearing me out on this.
Our on-line shop of replica watches ( offers the visitors a wide range of exclusive timepieces and watches of top quality. Here you are sure to discover watches featuring numerous designs, styles, innovative functions and complications. Nowadays more and more people refused to choose replica watches as they find it rather advantageous. Maybe, we will give you one more choice and opportunity.

Carrying brands including Rolex , BellRoss,Cartier, Hermes, Omega , Ferrari, IWC etc . We are direct manufacturer, Except the goods and services that our website provide, we also try our best to help you getting a unique product if you want your watch to suit all kinds of color and different dials to show you difference. For each customer and every sale is important to us. We have been providing 100% CUSTOMER SATISFACTION from our beginning. Our past customers have allowed us to grow by recommending our services. Our mission is to continue our 100% satisfaction to made watch being a pop-fashion and affect everyone instead a show of wealth, just because love.

All of our team is watch enthusiasts, we collect up to date information in watches market to keep our products new. We offer the lowest price on each watch in the similar products, we hope that our website will save you money and stay away from fraudulent dealers to take you great value. We offer competitive pricing, but we also knew low prices alone could not make our business superior. We are determined to combine honest and helpful dealings with outstanding service before, during, and after the sale. You can learn our latest service and commitment from our online services before you buy something.
I like to look for the best investment advice possible
It was a very nice article! Just want to say thank you for the information you have shared. Just continue writing this kind of post. Thanks.

Professional Business Plan
Get Free Nifty Tips
This was a good blog you had going - have you stopped updating it ?
Buffett Fan
Really Nice Blog and Very Good predictions and Free Intraday Stock Tips.
I liked your blog and I would recommend it to my friends who do trading in Free Intraday Trading Tips.
Earning money online never been this easy and transparent. You would find great tips on how to make that dream amount every month. So go ahead and click here for more details and open floodgates to your online income. All the best.
investissement dans l'immobilier Paris, immobilier neuf, conseils gratuits et appartements bien placés. le best of des offres
I really appreciate your post and you explain each and every point very well.Thanks for

sharing this information.And I’ll love to read your next post too.
stock Tips
I took a look at your site and recommend it to my visitors. I agree with you on the importance of becoming valuable in many different areas. I believe that it sustains any entrepreneur during challenges that inevitably occur.

commodity free trial tips $$ mcx tips free trial
I really appreciate your post and you explain each and every point very well.Thanks for sharing this information.And I'll love to read your next post too.


Mcx Tips
I give advise on penny stocks under five dollars. I have experience with these type of stocks for those investors looking for an exchange traded fund that invests in lithium stocks their is an exchange traded fund that invest in small company stocks in the lithium business it is Global X Lithium ETF symbol (LIT).
Thank you for blogging. . .
Vimax We learned tips for how to write on people's blogs, like a compliment.
We also learned that if you know something about the topic,Vimax you can put it on there if nobody else has written it. We liked the suggestion to only use one punctuation instead of a bunch if you liked it Vimax.
buffet:i lost the hope of saving the world,maybe.human just sometimes not worth i fighting greed and short sight.i thought if i can solve out the energy reservation code or find the very deep truth after the relativity theory,maybe we can make a ufo in the future or control the nuclear safely.i need to express it,maybe i should forget about the truth and just go directly earn money..i feel painful.i hope u can read this. It's a very very useful site! ! It will save your time!
Thanks so much for this! I haven't been this moved by a blog for a long time! You’ve got it, whatever that means in blogging. Anyway, You are definitely someone that has something to say that people need to hear. Keep up the good work. Keep on inspiring the people!

stock tips,nifty tips,commodity tips
thanks for this post. This post makes a great point about focusing your efforts.

stock tips,equity tips,stock market india | Currency Tips,Forex trading Tips,Forex Pairs | commodity tips
You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with your website.
free tips
BSE SENSEX and NIFTY rallied 300 points and 100 points respectively led by broad based buying. The NIFTY breached the resistance level of the 5200 mark as buying activity picked up across the board ahead of the Reserve Bank Of India’s policy meet tomorrow.
Stock Tips
BSE SENSEX and NIFTY rallied 300 points and 100 points respectively led by broad based buying. The NIFTY breached the resistance level of the 5200 mark as buying activity picked up across the board ahead of the Reserve Bank Of India’s policy meet tomorrow.

Stock Tips
Commodity Tips
This blog Is very informative,I am really pleased to post my comment on this blog.Very well explain NSE & BSE.
Stock Tips
This is one of the good articles you can find in the net explaining everything in detail regarding the topic. I thank you for taking your time sharing your thoughts and ideas to a lot of readers out there.
I strongly believe that studying Buffett's life and principles will make us more adept investors. I obsessively studied his life and investment style for many years and read every book I could lay my hands on in the process. This has made me somewhat of an expert on books written about Warren Buffett and I want to share my knowledge with you. If you are interested, kindly visit my recommendations on
Who could be the next Warren Buffett?

Really nice information.keep blogging. commodity Tips

Thanks for your great article. Thank you for this article. I spent many years studying Warren Buffett's investment approach and currently keep a blog on books that most interested his investment philosophy.
Please find my recommendations below:
This comment has been removed by the author.
Hi, I came across your site and wasn’t able to get an email address to contact you about a broken link on your site. Please email me back and I would be happy to point them out to you.


Aaron Grey
aarongrey112 at
Thanks for the knowledge. I found this blog is very Knowledgeable to read, i will visit again for more updates... Equity Tips
I am biggest fan of Warren. Read our tips on how to meet Warren Buffet.
Post a Comment

<< Home